Phone answering service for small business: how to choose one
Short answer: start from the calls you miss today, not from a provider's feature list. Decide whether you need messages taken or jobs booked, give the service your real hours, services and policies, then place five or six test calls of your own before you sign. The right phone answering service is the one that handles your callers correctly at 7 pm on a Friday, at a price that still makes sense in your busiest month.
Do I actually need a phone answering service?
Look at last month's call log from your phone provider before you shop. Most small businesses have a pattern, and the pattern tells you what kind of service you need.
- Calls ring out while you are working (on a job site, under a car, with a client): you need every call answered during the day, not only after hours.
- Calls arrive after closing and on weekends: you need after-hours coverage, and a clear rule for what counts as urgent. Our after-hours answering service guide shows how to set both up.
- The same few questions repeat (hours, location, "do you do X?", "how much for Y?"): the service needs to answer them, not only take a message.
- Most callers want an appointment: the service needs access to your real calendar, or you will spend your evenings calling people back to book.
If you miss only a few calls a week and they are all happy to wait for a call back, voicemail with a good greeting may be enough. If missed calls turn into jobs booked with a competitor, an answering service usually pays for itself.
What kinds of phone answering service are there?
| Type | Who answers | Good fit when |
|---|---|---|
| Message-taking answering service | Call-center agents on a short script | You only need names, numbers and reasons passed on |
| Live virtual receptionist | A remote person working from your notes | Calls need judgment, and volume is modest |
| Automated virtual receptionist | An automated voice system using your approved information | Calls are frequent, repetitive or after hours, and you want bookings made on the call |
Our virtual receptionist vs answering service guide compares the three in detail, and the cost guide covers pricing models and hidden fees. This guide is about choosing well once you know which type you want.
What should I hand over before it goes live?
A phone answering service is only as good as the information you give it. Prepare these before your first setup call; it will take an hour or two and saves weeks of wrong answers.
- Hours and closures: regular hours, holidays and the days you are booked solid.
- Services and what you don't do: "we don't work on diesel trucks" saves as many wasted calls as a list of what you do.
- Prices you are willing to say out loud: only fixed prices or clear ranges. Anything that needs an inspection should be "we'll quote after we see it."
- Booking rules: appointment types, how long each takes, how far ahead people can book, and how many jobs fit in a day. Our phone booking setup guide has a template.
- What counts as urgent, and who gets told: for example, a no-heat call in January, or a car that won't start in the shop's own lot.
- Transfer rules: which calls should reach a person, during which hours, and at which number.
- Your ten most common questions and your best answers to them.
How do I test a phone answering service before I sign?
Ask for a trial or a demo line set up with your own information, then call it yourself, and ask a friend to call it too. Try each of these:
- A simple question: "Are you open Saturday?" Is the answer right, and quick?
- A booking: does it offer real open times, avoid times you are closed, and send a confirmation?
- A question it should not answer: ask for an exact price on something that needs an inspection. A good service says it will have someone follow up instead of guessing.
- An urgent call after hours: does the urgent message reach you the way you asked?
- "Can I talk to a person?": what happens during your hours, and what happens after them?
- Background noise and a hard-to-spell name: is the message you get afterwards usable?
Then read what the service sends you: the message, the summary or transcript, and the booking in your calendar. If you would have to call the customer back to work out what they wanted, keep looking.
What privacy rules apply to answering services in Canada?
If the service records calls, the Office of the Privacy Commissioner of Canada says that under PIPEDA the organization must tell customers the call is being recorded and clearly state the purpose. If recording is not integral to the service, customers must be offered an alternative. Provincial privacy laws can add rules (for example, Quebec's Law 25), so check what applies to your business. Our guide to call recording consent in Canada covers what your greeting should say and what to do when a caller says no.
Practical questions for any provider:
- Is audio recorded, or only a transcript kept? Who can see it, and how long is it kept?
- What does the greeting tell callers, and can you change the wording?
- If it is an automated system, does it say so? Callers should never be led to think they are speaking with a person when they are not.
- Where is call data stored, and can you export or delete it if you leave?
What contract terms should I check?
- Phone number: do you forward your existing number, or get a new one? If you leave, what happens to that number?
- How usage is counted: per minute, per call or a monthly allowance, and whether spam and wrong numbers count.
- Overage and alerts: the rate past your allowance, and whether you are warned before it applies.
- Term and cancellation: monthly or annual, and the notice period.
- Setup fees and changes: is updating your hours or prices free and quick, or a support ticket with a fee?
- Reliability: is there a published availability target, and what happens to calls during an outage?
Where Sonic Receptionist fits
Sonic Receptionist, by SonicFront, is an automated virtual receptionist for service businesses. It answers every call 24/7 with an automated-call disclosure, answers only from information you approve, books, reschedules and cancels in Google Calendar within your opening hours, texts confirmations, takes messages with urgency, and transfers calls to your team during business hours. Calls are transcribed for your records, and audio recordings are not stored. Plans start at $249 USD per month; see pricing for what each plan includes. Its first live deployment is an auto repair shop in Toronto.
The best way to judge it is the same test above: we set it up with your hours and answers, and you call it.
Book a demo